The ‘perverse satisfaction’ in platforming hate

Eugenics, Professor Rebecca Sear describes, is a ‘coercive ideology’ where those in power ‘mak[e] value judgments about which traits are desirable or undesirable’. Just as historical records prove racial taxonomies were established to rationalise hierarchy and justify exploitation, comprehensive sequencing shows human genetic differences do not map onto racial boundaries. Regardless, pseudoscientific attempts to genetically justify racial hierarchies have been insistent on self-legitimisation since the 1960s—when scientific consensus overwhelmingly rejected publications rooted in long-discarded assumptions, journalistic echo chambers such as Mankind Quarterly were established to continue the guise of scientific method. The undying promotion of racial essentialism through illegitimate science takes the present-day stage with co-opted scientific and philosophical terminology, smoke-screening eugenics with labels such as ‘race realism’ and ‘hereditarianism’.

When eugenics bares its divisive teeth while swaddled in the wool of scientific theory, the words which inspire outrage are not accusations of ‘hallucinate[d] racism’, but the promotion of ‘diversity’, ‘equality’, and ‘inclusion’. Though the dominant demographic still imposes and benefits from systemic inequality, many view the enlarged provision of accessible opportunity as a targeted confiscation of entitled territory. Attempts towards equal opportunity in exclusionary spaces are catastrophised as systemic inversion hostile to the presently dominant group; concessions towards the marginalised are considered disproportionate bias. In a marriage between repackaged racism and demonised DEI initiatives, Oxford Reform Society invites self-proclaimed ‘race realist’ Nathan Cofnas to discuss—‘Is DEI Undermining Higher Education?’

Cofnas is best known for two events demarcating his racist rhetoric. First, his anti-DEI piece claiming Black people would, in ‘true’ meritocracy, ‘disappear from almost all high-profile positions outside of sports and entertainment’. Second, his detailed accusations targeting Professor Jason Arday’s academic competence and integrity, followed by Arday’s resignation from Cambridge University and subsequent death in August 2026. Cofnas’ ideology insists upon race-inherent traits, claiming ‘the preservation of racial distinctions’ is within the interests of those ‘truly valu[ing] diversity’. Despite his attempts to rebut DEI initiatives by appropriating inclusive language, his fundamentally incorrect premise conflates social immobility with preference for racial monoculture. The misattribution of agency when predicting that ‘many self-segregating communities will be relatively homogenous’ proves his incomplete understanding of our status quo, thus rendering his propositions unworthy of consideration. 

How to Take Back Academia (2023) shows awareness that academic and political consensus firmly contradicts and disapproves of his ideology. Cofnas demands his Substack readers respond to rejection by joining the hereditarian revolution as a ‘fight against wokism’, to take decisive action even when ‘being a loser can turn into a habit, an identity, and a perverse satisfaction.’ Dismissed from Cambridge University’s Emmanuel College in 2024 and suspended by Ghent University with pending investigation into discrimination in 2026, his denouncement of self-victimisation can be recategorised as self-diagnosis. It seems Cofnas himself now indulges in the ‘perverse satisfaction’ of ‘being a loser’, ceaselessly writing and speaking on becoming a ‘scapegoat’ in sociopolitical controversy. Despite now embodying the response he once deemed unproductive, his current role in public discourse is indeed one to capitalise on, even guaranteeing support from contrarians.

Perfectly embodying the privileged thinker’s false equivalence between DEI policy and structural inequality, Oxford Reform Society declares their platforming of Cofnas shall ‘remov[e] systemic barriers for marginalised voice’ and ‘[resist] the performative victimhood of dominant groups seeking to manufacture their own marginalisation’. When the ‘marginalised voice’ in question justifies pseudoscientific eugenics and the society’s defence erases the extensive history of racial oppression, exploitation, and exclusion, promises of ‘inclusive dialogue’ are impossible to accept. Shifting attention to the administrative level, Oriel College has also received backlash for ruling the event permissible: The Oriel Code of Practice on Freedom of Speech declares desire for a ‘culture of openness and inclusion’, and states that ‘free, open robust discussion can be achieved only if all concerned engage critically but courteously with each other’ (3.2–4.1).

All too often is the duty of compromise, reconciliation, and forgiveness placed on those who suffer—historically and presently—under oppressive structures which barely admit to their own existence. Oxford is certainly practiced in the motions of creating controversy and brushing off backlash, particularly the Oxford Union: Alan Dershowitz. Tommy Robinson. Ehud Olmert. Charlie Kirk. These names only briefly recount recent instances of amplifying violent or exploitative ideology; doubtless more invitations are to come. With every spotlight better left unlit, every platform better left collapsed, the debate on entitlement to free speech and hate speech revives, student unions and city councils express dissent, yet the responsible organisational bodies remain unaffected.

Toni Morrison’s words on this cruelly insistent cycle are ever relevant: ‘the very serious function of racism is distraction. It keeps you from doing your work. It keeps you explaining, over and over again, your reason for being.’ It is exhausting to eloquently rebut illogical words, and yet any less would be inadequate. ‘None of this is necessary. There will always be one more thing.’ 

 

Words by Remie Cheng.

Art by Naia Searight